Reasonable Doubt (Recap) | Friend or Foe (S3 E4)

by Tim Gordon

The episode opens with Jax (Emayatzy Corinealdi) and Daniel (Tim Jo) showing up unannounced at Ozzie’s (Kyle Barry) place to speak with his sister, Kristen (Kiah Clingman). Jax is convinced Kristen is holding back details about the night Ozzie overdosed and how he got the drugs. She instructs Daniel to keep a close watch on her, which he eagerly accepts.

Meanwhile, Bill (Joseph Sikora) continues his attempts to reconcile with his wife, Kendra (Brittany Inge). He shows up with flowers, but his gesture falls flat. Kendra makes it clear that she is still furious about his prioritizing career over marriage and that it will take far more than flowers to win her back. Later, Bill earns some ground when he spends the weekend with their kids, but the wounds in their relationship remain raw.

Elsewhere, Sam (Martin Jakes Jr.) admits to Lewis (McKinley Freeman) that he lied on his application and is learning skills on the side. He appeals to their shared Black identity to excuse his lack of qualifications. Lewis initially shows sympathy but later feels betrayed when Sam manipulates him again at work, forcing Lewis to put him on notice.

Jax and her team prepare for jury selection, dissecting Ozzie’s personal life to gain sympathy. She even brings in Sue from accounting as a mock juror model, channeling her inner Olivia Pope to frame Ozzie’s case with precision. Ozzie later shocks his parents, Rosie (April Parker Jones) and Sal (Keith Arthur Bolden), by admitting he was sexually abused. Though they are devastated, he refuses to name his abuser.

At home, Jax and Lewis share a brief moment of intimacy before Naima (Aderinsola Olabode) storms in with proof of Lewis’ past infidelity. The revelation leads to a heated family meeting. Naima, deeply hurt, confronts her father for hiding the truth and leaves both parents reeling with the cutting remark: “Why do you guys like to ruin everything?” The fallout highlights just how fragile the trust in their home really is.

Eddie (Richard Brooks) reemerges and is met with suspicion by Spencer (Thaddeus J. Mixson) and Naima. He eventually wins them over, though Lewis remains openly hostile. Their confrontation simmers with tension as Eddie refuses to back down, insisting he belongs in Jax’s and the kids’ lives. The episode builds Eddie’s presence into a major source of conflict, positioning him as both a destabilizing force and a father figure Lewis is unwilling to accept.

Later, Jax finds a momentary reprieve during a girls’ night with Autumn (Tiffany Yvonne Cox), Shanelle (Shannon Kane), and Sally (Nefetari Spencer). Autumn surprises the group with a pregnancy announcement, while Sally privately confesses to Jax that she has rekindled things with her ex, Chris. Their banter turns combative until Shanelle and Autumn rejoin, prompting Sally and Jax to mask their argument as though nothing happened.

Meanwhile, Daniel’s growing bond with Kristen takes a dangerous turn when she lets slip that Ozzie keeps a journal. Ozzie warns her not to jeopardize his case, but Daniel schemes his way back into the house and uncovers potentially damning evidence. He alerts Jax, hinting at explosive revelations about Ozzie’s abuser.

The episode ends with Lewis and Eddie facing off in a heated exchange, each man challenging the other’s place in Jax’s world. With jury selection underway and Jax finally seating the jurors she needs, the stage is set for the trial — but the personal lives of everyone orbiting her are spinning further out of control.


Final Thoughts

This episode sharpens the tension on every front. Jax is juggling a complex, high-stakes defense while her family life teeters on the brink of collapse. Ozzie’s secrets continue to unravel, Kristen may be in over her head, and Daniel could prove more liability than ally. Lewis and Eddie’s showdown promises long-term fallout, while Bill’s attempts to reconcile with Kendra underscore the theme of fractured families running throughout the season.

The case is heating up, but so are the personal stakes. The line between friend and foe has never felt thinner.